Research · The case for a new approach to elementary social studies

Our children deserve a stronger foundation in history and civic understanding.

Elementary school is where children begin building the historical knowledge and civic understanding that shape how they see the world. Yet national assessments reveal troubling gaps in what American students know about U.S. history and democratic institutions. Understanding these gaps requires examining the foundations we build during the elementary years.

The Nation’s Report Card · 2022

What do American eighth graders know about history and civics?

40%

of eighth graders scored below NAEP Basic in U.S. history.

31%

scored below NAEP Basic in civics.

−9 pts

Average U.S. history score compared with 2014 (−5 since 2018).

1st

decline in average civics scores since 1998 (−2 points from 2018).

NAEP Proficient is not the same as grade-level proficiency: NCES notes that it “does not signify meeting grade level expectations, which are set through state assessments.” These results also do not show that elementary curriculum is their cause—eighth-grade outcomes reflect many years of influences in and out of school. They do raise a serious question about the foundation we build in the elementary years, when children first formally study history and civics.

01 · Marginalized

Elementary social studies is being squeezed out of the school day.

Despite its importance to historical understanding and civic education, elementary social studies receives far less instructional time than reading and mathematics—a disparity reinforced by decades of educational priorities and accountability policies.

A. Instructional time

Teachers of self-contained K–3 classes reported an average of 89 minutes a day on reading and language arts, 57 on mathematics, 18 on science, and just 16 on social studies (2018 NSSME+, a nationally representative survey).

In many schools, science and social studies share one block and alternate by day, week, or unit.

Illustrative daily schedule for an elementary classroom: arrival, morning circle, reading workshop, math workshop, lunch, read-aloud and phonics, specials, writing workshop, then one shared 40-minute block labeled Science / Social Studies before dismissal.

Illustrative example of a daily schedule with one shared science/social studies block.

B. Accountability and educational priorities

The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 required annual testing in reading and mathematics and attached consequences to the results. Between 2001–02 and 2006–07, school districts reported shifting time toward the tested subjects—and away from social studies, which lost an average of 76 minutes per week in districts that cut it (Center on Education Policy, 2008).

Infographic: 58% of districts added reading time; 44% added math time; 28% cut science time; 36% cut social studies time, by 76 minutes per week on average.

District-reported changes since 2001–02 (McMurrer, 2008, Center on Education Policy).

C. Testing and accountability

Unlike reading, mathematics, and science, elementary social studies has no federal testing requirement. In a national analysis of 2007–08 data, only about a dozen states tested elementary social studies, and teachers in states that tested it at every grade reported about 30 more minutes of social studies per week. That is an association, not evidence that testing causes more instruction (Fitchett et al., 2014).

02 · Fragmented

Traditional curriculum organization can scramble the story of the past.

Fragmentation takes two forms: dividing the world into geographic settings assigned to different grades, and dividing knowledge into separate disciplinary units.

A. Geographic fragmentation

Illustrated poster of the Expanding Environments Model: concentric circles labeled Kindergarten = Family, 1st = Community, 2nd = City, 3rd = State, 4th = Early Nation, 5th = Late Nation. Established late 1800s, popularized 1900s.
A brief history of the Expanding Environments Model: what it is, where it came from, and why it stuck.

A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE EEM

What it is: a framework that gives each K–5 grade one “environment,” starting with the family in kindergarten and “expanding outward” each year.

Where it came from: German educator Johann Herbart’s 1800s “home studies.” Charles McMurry brought it to U.S. schools in the 1890s, a 1916 national report codified it, and Paul Hanna’s best-selling textbooks (1930s–1950s) made it the national norm it remains today.

Why it stuck: it fit a popular belief that young children understand only what is near and familiar. Piaget’s stage theory, influential by the mid-1900s, was later used to label it “developmentally appropriate.”

Akenson, 1989; Barton, 2009; Halvorsen, 2013, pp. 3–5; LeRiche, 1987; Stallones, 2002; Vygotsky, 1978

Because each grade is assigned a place rather than a story, local, national, and global histories are often taught years apart, which can obscure how they connect. The approach also assumed young children could understand only what is near and familiar. Research suggests children can investigate broader historical and global questions when instruction is thoughtfully designed (Bickmore, 1999).

Educational historians have questioned the Expanding Environments approach for decades. Halvorsen (2013) documents both longstanding concerns about its limited disciplinary depth and its remarkable persistence in elementary social studies, despite the development of alternative approaches (pp. 3–5). That history explains the model’s influence; it does not mean every current curriculum follows it or that it is ineffective everywhere.

Comparison. What K–2 standards often ask for: community helpers, state symbols, dressing up as famous people. Versus what young children can do: understand big, difficult history; discuss real-world issues; take civic action.
Comparison. What K–2 standards often ask for: community helpers, state symbols, dressing up as famous people. What young children can do: understand big, difficult history; discuss real-world issues; take civic action.
Illustration of a child connected to icons for another country, moves often, no stable home, and visiting: “My family” and “my community” mean very different things to a child who is an immigrant, a refugee, unhoused, or has moved many times.
“My family” and “my community” mean very different things to a child who is an immigrant, a refugee, unhoused, or has moved many times.
NCSS agrees: The field's national organization calls the model “insufficient for today's young learners.” (NCSS, 2017)

NCSS (2017), Powerful, Purposeful Pedagogy in Elementary School Social Studies; replaced by a new position statement in 2024.

NCSS AGREES

The field’s national organization calls the model “insufficient for today’s young learners.”

NCSS, 2017; statement replaced in 2024

B. Disciplinary fragmentation

History, geography, economics, civics, and culture each offer essential concepts and ways of thinking. Opalis does not reject disciplinary knowledge or standards. The concern is treating disciplinary categories as boundaries that dictate how curriculum must be organized—a geography unit, then a history unit, then economics, then civics.

Real events involve people, places, resources, and power at once. The C3 Framework itself calls for inquiry that draws on disciplinary concepts and tools together, and a randomized study found that integrated, project-based social studies and literacy units significantly increased second graders’ social studies learning (Duke et al., 2021).

Illustration of four grain silos labeled Geography Standards, History Standards, Economics Standards, and Civics Standards, with an arrow to 'Curriculum follows the standards': Unit 1 Geography, Unit 2 History, Unit 3 Economics, Unit 4 Civics.
Illustration of a puzzled child next to icons for state capital, community helpers, Native Americans, and state seal, asking: What does my state capital, community helpers, Native Americans, and my state seal have to do with each other?
A puzzled child asks: What does my state capital, community helpers, Native Americans, and my state seal have to do with each other?

Not every traditional curriculum is fragmented in the same ways, and many teachers build connections on their own. The concern is structural: when connections depend on individual teachers rather than curriculum design, coherence is left to chance.

03 · Narrow

Historical narratives are often incomplete—and every child is shortchanged.

Every child deserves a fuller understanding of human history. Yet research has documented how curriculum standards and instructional materials can omit entire communities, reduce complex histories to a few famous individuals, or portray people primarily through oppression and hardship. These incomplete narratives limit what children learn about the past—and one another.

The findings below come from different kinds of evidence—state standards, a textbook, and online resources—and do not mean every curriculum shares the same gaps.

A. Whose histories are included?

STATE STANDARDS

87%

of state U.S. history standards that included Indigenous Peoples placed them in a pre-1900 context—relegating Indigenous nations to the distant past.

Shear et al., 2015; Shear, 2015

STATE STANDARDS

14 + DC

As of July 2023, only 14 states and the District of Columbia (29% of jurisdictions) had academic standards for Asian American and Pacific Islander studies.

Committee of 100, 2023

B. How are those histories told?

ELEMENTARY STANDARDS

2

individuals—Martin Luther King Jr. and Rosa Parks—received credit for generations of collective Black activism in K–5 standards, “sanitized to fit within the master narrative of American progress.”

Busey & Walker, 2017

A TEXTBOOK EXAMPLE

“Workers”

A 2015 ninth-grade world geography textbook approved in Texas described the Atlantic slave trade as bringing “millions of workers from Africa.” The publisher revised it after public objection.

Texas Tribune, 2015

ONLINE RESOURCES

Clip art

Analyses of elementary resources on online curriculum marketplaces documented problematic Black history narratives and what one study calls “exceptionalist narratives and faceless clip art” in Indigenous history resources.

Rodríguez et al., 2020, 2023

C. What perspectives are missing?

When history centers mainly on oppression, conflict, or a few prominent leaders, children can miss the cultural knowledge, creativity, intellectual contributions, everyday experiences, and collective agency that also define human communities.

Comparison. What's too often taught, limited to pain and stripped of agency: framed only by oppression, poverty, or conflict; stereotyped and one-dimensional; voices silenced or erased. What we need more of, full histories and full humanity: stories of joy, brilliance, resilience, and leadership; many perspectives and experiences; multiple voices that shape our past and future.
What's too often taught versus what we need more of: full histories and full humanity.

04 · Without context

Difficult histories are often introduced without the background children need.

When historical learning is fragmented or limited to isolated commemorations, children may encounter difficult events without the background knowledge needed to understand them. Teachers are then left to explain complex histories in a single lesson—often without sufficient curriculum guidance or time.

A TEACHER’S EXPERIENCE

Each February, during Black History Month, a kindergarten teacher’s students asked why Black and white people were once kept apart. With no curriculum that had built the history beforehand, she was left trying to explain segregation and centuries of history in a few short lessons—and her young students were left with confusion and harmful misconceptions instead of understanding.

Paraphrased from a kindergarten teacher’s account in Dr. Genevieve Erker Caffrey’s research

Difficult histories should be taught with sufficient context, alongside the dignity, agency, creativity, and complexity of the people studied.

05 · Unsupported

Teachers lack coherent curriculum infrastructure.

Elementary teachers are often expected to teach complex histories without a comprehensive curriculum, sufficient background knowledge, or consistent instructional support. National research reveals how frequently teachers must assemble their own materials—and how much additional preparation schools need.

A. Teachers are expected to assemble their own curriculum.

16%

of K–5 teachers primarily use a district-required or recommended published social studies curriculum.

Diliberti et al., 2023 (RAND)

52%

piece together (“cobble”) materials from multiple sources.

Diliberti et al., 2023 (RAND)

Bar: 16% textbook, 9% local, 22% make their own, 52% piece together (cobble) materials.

Primary source of materials for most social studies instructional time: 16% a district-required or recommended published curriculum; 9% locally developed materials; 22% self-created materials; 52% pieced together from multiple sources. Diliberti et al. (2023), Figure 9.

Primary source of materials for most social studies instructional time: 16% a district-required or recommended published curriculum; 9% locally developed materials; 22% self-created materials; 52% pieced together from multiple sources. Diliberti et al. (2023), Figure 9.

Of the teachers who cobble materials together, more than a third use no curriculum regularly. In social studies, 59% of teachers say teachers—themselves or others in their school system—are the primary decision-makers about materials, compared with 32% in English language arts.

Chart of materials elementary teachers use at least once per week: materials I create myself 51%, school- or district-created 28%, Studies Weekly 16%, myWorld Interactive (Savvas) 7%, Social Studies Alive! (TCI) 4%, IMPACT (McGraw Hill) 4%, Into Social Studies (HMH) 3%, no curriculum used regularly 18%.

Materials K–5 teachers reported using at least once a week (select all that apply). Diliberti et al. (2023), Table A.4.

Materials K–5 teachers reported using at least once a week (select all that apply). Diliberti et al. (2023), Table A.4.

B. Teachers need more historical knowledge and instructional preparation.

Only 42% of elementary teachers reported feeling very well prepared to teach social studies, compared with 77% for reading and language arts and 73% for mathematics.

Teaching social studies well requires substantial knowledge of history, geography, civics, and economics—and of how to teach difficult topics with care.

C. Schools lack consistent instructional guidance.

76% of elementary principals say their teachers need more professional learning on social studies standards, content, or teaching methods. 9% say a common set of social studies teaching practices is used by all teachers in their school to a large extent.

76% of elementary principals said teachers needed “a little more” or “a lot more” professional learning on social studies standards, content, or pedagogy; 9% said a set of social studies teaching practices used by all teachers was present “to a large extent.” Diliberti et al. (2023).

76% of elementary principals say teachers need more social studies professional learning; 9% report common teaching practices to a large extent.

76% of elementary principals said teachers needed “a little more” or “a lot more” professional learning on social studies standards, content, or pedagogy; 9% said a set of social studies teaching practices used by all teachers was present “to a large extent.” Diliberti et al. (2023).

Chart comparing elementary principals' reports by subject. Provides a published curriculum: math 94%, ELA 94%, science 84%, social studies 55%. Evaluates teachers' instruction: 98%, 98%, 74%, 67%. Offers teacher training: 89%, 95%, 51%, 52%.

Elementary principals reporting that their school or district provides a published curriculum (required or recommended), evaluates teachers’ instruction, and offers professional-development workshops. Science data are from 2021. Diliberti et al. (2023). An industry survey also reported that 40% of K–5 educators lacked a core social studies program (Simba Information, 2019, as cited in Gross et al., 2024).

Elementary principals reporting that their school or district provides a published curriculum (required or recommended), evaluates teachers’ instruction, and offers professional-development workshops. Science data are from 2021. Diliberti et al. (2023). An industry survey also reported that 40% of K–5 educators lacked a core social studies program (Simba Information, 2019, as cited in Gross et al., 2024).

06 · Scattered resources

Teachers fill the gaps with resources that are scattered and unevenly reviewed.

A. Finding resources is not the same as having a curriculum.

When schools lack a comprehensive social studies curriculum, teachers must find, evaluate, organize, and connect individual resources themselves. Even high-quality lessons can become fragmented when they aren’t designed to build historical knowledge and understanding across units and grade levels.

A TEACHER’S EXPERIENCE

“If I am handed one more link, one more website, one more toolkit, and expected to stitch together sensitive, important content on my own… I’m going to lose it! This important work should be done by experts and done coherently.”

— St. Louis fifth-grade teacher, quoted with permission

Chart comparing teachers who use each resource weekly with principals whose school requires or recommends it: Teachers Pay Teachers 70% vs 16%; BrainPOP 60% vs 32%; YouTube 48% vs 10%; Google searches 31% vs 9%. Callout: 4 times as many teachers use Teachers Pay Teachers each week as principals who recommend it.

K–5 teachers using each resource at least weekly, compared with elementary principals whose school or district requires or recommends it. Diliberti et al. (2023), Tables A.2 and A.5.

K–5 teachers using each resource at least weekly, compared with elementary principals whose school or district requires or recommends it. Diliberti et al. (2023), Tables A.2 and A.5.

B. Quality and coherence are different challenges.

Outstanding resources—lessons, primary-source collections, instructional tools—already exist. Teachers still need a coherent roadmap that connects them, provides historical context, and builds learning across K–12.

Quality varies, and teachers carry the burden of judging it. Studies of elementary resources on online curriculum marketplaces have documented problematic portrayals of Black and Indigenous history (Rodríguez et al., 2020, 2023). A separate study of best-selling U.S. history resources for middle and high school rated 70% of moderate or low quality and 30% potentially harmful (Harris et al., 2023).

This is not a judgment of any platform or of the many skilled educators who create materials—Opalis itself shares a published resource through Teachers Pay Teachers. The need is for coherent, historically grounded, comprehensive curriculum and reliable instructional support.

VALUABLE RESOURCES WE ADMIRE

Zinn Education Project · Learning for Justice · Facing History & Ourselves · The Choices Program · CIRCLE (Tufts University) · and many others.

Opalis will point teachers to many of them. A coherent K⁠–⁠12 curriculum gives these resources a place in a larger story.

07 · Why it matters

Elementary social studies is not an expendable enrichment subject.

Elementary social studies does more than teach children about the past. It builds the background knowledge that supports learning across subjects and develops the historical and civic understanding needed to participate thoughtfully in society.

A. Building knowledge strengthens learning across subjects.

CORRELATIONAL · NATIONAL DATA

More social studies, stronger reading

About 30 more minutes of social studies a day was associated with fifth-grade reading scores about 0.15 standard deviations higher; more English language arts time was not.

Tyner & Kabourek, 2020

RANDOMIZED TRIAL

Integrated units raise learning

Second graders in low-income schools taught through integrated, project-based units made significantly greater social studies gains. Their informational-reading gains were also larger, but not statistically significant.

Duke et al., 2021

RESEARCH ON BACKGROUND KNOWLEDGE

Knowledge supports comprehension

Prior knowledge of a topic mattered as much as general reading ability for understanding a text, and building content knowledge can support comprehension in the primary grades.

Recht & Leslie, 1988; Cabell & Hwang, 2020

B. Historical and civic understanding prepare children for participation in society.

NCSS argues that “if the young learners of this nation are to become effective participants in a democratic society, then social studies must be an essential part of the curriculum throughout the elementary years.” Research syntheses link high-quality civic learning with greater civic knowledge and participation (Gould, 2011).

Infographic. Knowledge: 91% of adults can't name all five First Amendment freedoms; 74% couldn't identify all five factual news statements as facts; 30% can't name all three branches of government. Voting: the U.S. ranks 31st in voter turnout among 50 countries; 47% of 18- to 29-year-olds voted in 2024; in 70% of the 50 largest U.S. cities, most registered voters skipped the last mayoral election.

Annenberg Public Policy Center (2025; about 9% could name all five freedoms); Pew Research Center (2018); Pew Research Center (2022; voting-age turnout, 50 countries); CIRCLE (2025); Hajnal & Green (2024; registered voters, 2021–2024 mayoral elections).

Adult civic knowledge and participation statistics: 91%, 74%, 30%, 31st, 47%, 70%.

Annenberg Public Policy Center (2025; about 9% could name all five freedoms); Pew Research Center (2018); Pew Research Center (2022; voting-age turnout, 50 countries); CIRCLE (2025); Hajnal & Green (2024; registered voters, 2021–2024 mayoral elections).

These adult outcomes are broader context. Many factors shape them, and they cannot be attributed directly to elementary social studies instruction.

Putting it all together

The problem isn’t a shortage of good intentions. It’s a shortage of coherent curriculum.

Teachers and educational organizations are doing extraordinary work, but individual lessons, disconnected resources, and fragmented instructional approaches cannot substitute for a comprehensive curriculum. Elementary social studies needs an approach that connects historical knowledge, diverse perspectives, disciplinary understanding, and meaningful civic learning—while providing teachers with the guidance and materials to make it possible.

What we're doing isn't working well enough. Too little time: often squeezed out by tested subjects. Too little support: limited curriculum, training, and guidance. Scattered resources: teachers assemble lessons from unevenly reviewed sources. A century-old framework: the Expanding Environments Model can scramble the story. Siloed disciplines: history, geography, civics, and economics often taught apart. Incomplete stories: histories too often softened, frozen in time, or missing. Better versions of the same structure won't fix this. Elementary social studies needs a fundamentally different approach to curriculum design.
What we're doing isn't working well enough. Too little time: often squeezed out by tested subjects. Too little support: limited curriculum, training, and guidance. Scattered resources: teachers assemble lessons from unevenly reviewed sources. A century-old framework: the Expanding Environments Model can scramble the story. Siloed disciplines: history, geography, civics, and economics often taught apart. Incomplete stories: histories too often softened, frozen in time, or missing. Better versions of the same structure won't fix this. Elementary social studies needs a fundamentally different approach to curriculum design.
Venn diagram. Typical textbooks: coherent and sequenced, but often organized by the Expanding Environments Model, often siloed by discipline, and hard history often softened. Assembled resources: many excellent pieces, but no shared sequence, quality varies widely, and hours of teacher time. At the overlap, Opalis is designed to be coherent and engaging, research-based, and built for teachers. Our design goals: coherent, culturally conscious, civically empowering, honest, joyful, balanced.
Venn diagram. Typical textbooks: coherent and sequenced, but often organized by the Expanding Environments Model, often siloed by discipline, and hard history often softened. Assembled resources: many excellent pieces, but no shared sequence, quality varies widely, and hours of teacher time. At the overlap, Opalis is designed to be coherent and engaging, research-based, and built for teachers. Our design goals: coherent, culturally conscious, civically empowering, honest, joyful, balanced.

Coherence is necessary but not sufficient. The Opalis response also includes historical breadth, responsible representation, integrated curricular design, meaningful inquiry, and substantive teacher support.

Our response

A different approach to elementary social studies.

Opalis is developing a comprehensive K⁠–⁠12 social studies curriculum to address these challenges. Eight commitments guide it, grouped below. The benefits described on this page are design goals; the curriculum is still in development.

01

Curricular architecture

The Opalis Helix brings three braided spirals—Integrated Disciplines, Geographic Environments, and Content & Skills—together across K⁠–⁠12, connected throughout by the five P.O.W.E.R. dimensions.

02

Historical knowledge & responsible representation

Units build the background knowledge that comprehension and civic understanding depend on. Dignity comes before harm, injustice is paired with resistance, and difficult histories are taught with developmental care.

03

Meaningful inquiry & civic learning

Students weigh evidence and perspectives to reach their own conclusions—no predetermined positions—and connect what they learn to informed participation.

04

Comprehensive materials & integrated review

Teacher Guides, Slide Decks, Student Workbooks, and Interactive Activities, with historical, developmental, and editorial expertise built into the writing process.

Sources

Research & References

Short citations appear beside each statistic on this page. The full list of 30 sources—linked to the original publications wherever possible—is below. Graphics are adapted from Dr. Genevieve Erker Caffrey’s research presentations.

View all research sources (30)
  1. Annenberg Public Policy Center. (2025, September 11). Americans’ knowledge of civics increases, Annenberg survey finds.
  2. Banilower, E. R., Smith, P. S., Malzahn, K. A., Plumley, C. L., Gordon, E. M., & Hayes, M. L. (2018). Report of the 2018 NSSME+. Horizon Research, Inc.
  3. Bickmore, K. (1999). Elementary curriculum about conflict resolution: Can children handle global politics? Theory & Research in Social Education, 27(1), 45–69.
  4. Busey, C. L., & Walker, I. (2017). A dream and a bus: Black critical patriotism in elementary social studies standards. Theory & Research in Social Education, 45(4), 456–488.
  5. Cabell, S. Q., & Hwang, H. (2020). Building content knowledge to boost comprehension in the primary grades. Reading Research Quarterly, 55(S1), S99–S107.
  6. Committee of 100. (2023). AAPI and ethnic studies requirements for K–12 students in America’s public schools: A state-by-state analysis.
  7. DeSilver, D. (2022, November 1). Turnout in U.S. has soared in recent elections but by some measures still trails that of many other countries. Pew Research Center.
  8. Diliberti, M. K., Woo, A., & Kaufman, J. H. (2023). The missing infrastructure for elementary (K–5) social studies instruction: Findings from the 2022 American Instructional Resources Survey (RR-A134-17). RAND Corporation.
  9. Duke, N. K., Halvorsen, A.-L., Strachan, S. L., Kim, J., & Konstantopoulos, S. (2021). Putting PjBL to the test: The impact of project-based learning on second graders’ social studies and literacy learning and motivation in low-SES school settings. American Educational Research Journal, 58(1), 160–200.
  10. Fitchett, P. G., Heafner, T. L., & Lambert, R. G. (2014). Examining elementary social studies marginalization: A multilevel model. Educational Policy, 28(1), 40–68.
  11. Gould, J. (Ed.). (2011). Guardian of democracy: The civic mission of schools. Leonore Annenberg Institute for Civics & Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools.
  12. Gross, C., Imel, K., & Allison, C. (2024). Social studies curriculum review landscape. American Institutes for Research & EdReports. (Citing Simba Information, 2019, K–12 Social Studies Market Survey Report.)
  13. Hajnal, Z., & Green, A. (2024). Big cities, tiny votes. Yankelovich Center for Social Science Research, UC San Diego.
  14. Halvorsen, A.-L. (2013). A history of elementary social studies: Romance and reality. Peter Lang.
  15. Harris, L. M., Archambault, L., & Shelton, C. C. (2023). Issues of quality on Teachers Pay Teachers: An exploration of best-selling U.S. history resources. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 55(4), 608–627.
  16. McMurrer, J. (2008). Instructional time in elementary schools: A closer look at changes for specific subjects. Center on Education Policy.
  17. Medina, A., & Hilton, K. (2025, April 14). New data: Nearly half of youth voted in 2024. CIRCLE, Tufts University.
  18. Merod, A. (2023, March 9). IXL Learning acquires Teachers Pay Teachers. K-12 Dive.
  19. Mitchell, A., Gottfried, J., Barthel, M., & Sumida, N. (2018, June 18). Distinguishing between factual and opinion statements in the news. Pew Research Center.
  20. National Center for Education Statistics. (2023). NAEP report card: 2022 NAEP civics assessment.
  21. National Center for Education Statistics. (2023). NAEP report card: 2022 NAEP U.S. history assessment.
  22. National Center for Education Statistics. (n.d.). NAEP achievement levels.
  23. National Council for the Social Studies. (2017). Powerful, purposeful pedagogy in elementary school social studies [Position statement; replaced in 2024].
  24. National Council for the Social Studies. (2013). The College, Career, and Civic Life (C3) Framework for Social Studies State Standards.
  25. Recht, D. R., & Leslie, L. (1988). Effect of prior knowledge on good and poor readers’ memory of text. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80(1), 16–20.
  26. Rodríguez, N. N., Brown, M., & Vickery, A. (2020). Pinning for profit? Examining elementary preservice teachers’ critical analysis of online social studies resources about Black history. Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education, 20(3), 497–528.
  27. Rodríguez, N. N., Brown, M., Updegraff, A., & Vickery, A. E. (2023). Exceptionalist narratives and faceless clip art: Critically analyzing Indigenous history resources found on online curriculum marketplaces. Teaching and Teacher Education, 124, 104009.
  28. Shear, S. B., Knowles, R. T., Soden, G. J., & Castro, A. J. (2015). Manifesting destiny: Re/presentations of Indigenous Peoples in K–12 U.S. history standards. Theory & Research in Social Education, 43(1), 68–101.
  29. Texas Tribune. (2015, October 7). Publisher offers stickers to cover divisive caption.
  30. Tyner, A., & Kabourek, S. (2020). Social studies instruction and reading comprehension: Evidence from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study. Thomas B. Fordham Institute.